Republican Rep. Mike Lawler conceded defeat Tuesday night to challenger Cait Conley, flipping a key seat in the Democratic Party’s bid to retake control of the House of Representatives.
The Associated Press had not yet called the race in the Hudson Valley as of 11 p.m. Malfunctioning voting machines in Westchester County delayed ballot scanning in the heavily Democratic area. But with a blue wave sweeping across the country, Lawler told supporters he had lost.
The race between Lawler and Conley was one of the most expensive in the country in terms of both candidate and outside spending. Lawler’s political base is in Rockland County, where strong turnout in past elections helped propel him to victory.
Democrat Cait Conley and Republican Rep. Mike Lawler
The national Democratic Party has tried to oust Lawler since he was first elected in 2022 in a district with more enrolled Democrats than Republicans. He was one of only a handful of Republicans who won their seats last cycle despite voters in their congressional district supporting Harris for president.
Lawler tried to stress his independent streak, highlighting times he’s opposed President Donald Trump. At the same time, he campaigned alongside Trump and voted for his signature “One Big Beautiful Bill” tax cut.
Conley sought to tie Lawler to Trump at every opportunity, calling Lawler a “puppet” of the president. She won a crowded primary in June to challenge the Republican incumbent.
Conley, a former Army officer and counterterrorism official, hoped for strong turnout in the parts of the district in northern Westchester County, which backed Vice President Kamala Harris by more than 25 points in the 2024 presidential election.
The New York State Board of Elections said the voting snafu stemmed from some scanning machines not getting a needed programming update, preventing them from reading and recognizing the paper ballots. Ballot-reading software was updated on machines in a single Westchester municipality but not elsewhere in the county.
The BOE said it collected and secured ballots in bags until it could properly scan and count them.
“Accuracy will never be sacrificed for speed,” the BOE said in a statement.