Mayor Zohran Mamdani says the city has a new tool in its fight against bad landlords: a legal maneuver typically used to punish fraud.
The city’s Law Department on Tuesday sued landlord Barry Singer in Bronx Supreme Court, arguing that he and the limited liability companies he controls violated the New York False Claims Act by evading more than $1 million in fines and emergency repairs completed by the city’s housing agency at 10 of his apartment buildings. Singer is a longtime fixture of the public advocate’s annual “worst landlord list,” ranking third on the most recent roster after accumulating thousands of open housing code violations.
The False Claims Act typically allows city and state governments to sue contractors, healthcare providers and other entities that submit fraudulent invoices or requests for repayment. Companies found guilty are required to pay triple damages for their misconduct.
The new city lawsuit contends that a section of the legislation also empowers it to sue any person or company who “knowingly and improperly avoids” paying money they owe, as in the case of Singer and unpaid fines levied by the Office of Administrative Trial Hearings, the Environmental Control Board and the city’s health and housing agencies.
The complaint says Singer could be on the hook for roughly $8 million if found guilty. Singer did not respond to a phone message left with his attorney.
The lawsuit is Mamdani's latest tactic to punish irresponsible landlords and potentially pry buildings away from owners who rack up violations or face financial distress. Since taking office, the mayor has pursued various methods for turning those buildings over to new groups that city officials deem more responsible. Those include intervening ahead of bankruptcy and foreclosure auctions and backing legislation that would give nonprofits first dibs on some buildings before they hit the open market. The efforts have generated support among tenant organizers but elicited furious opposition from landlord groups and their allies.
Mamdani said the city’s usual tactics for holding landlords accountable — violations and fines — has not worked in the case of Singer, and other chronically negligent owners.
“When the same old tools fail to deliver results, we will use new strategies to hold noncompliant landlords accountable and win justice for tenants,” the mayor said in a statement. “Every New Yorker deserves a safe, well-maintained home, and we will use every tool at our disposal to make that a reality across the five boroughs.”
The lawsuit lists 10 buildings with a combined 299 apartments controlled by Singer, many of them located in the Bronx's Allerton, Kingsbridge and Fordham neighborhoods. One 58-unit building at 2500 Webb Ave. has 456 open housing code violations, including 183 deemed immediately hazardous for problems like a leaky roof, broken brick walls and roach infestations, according to city data.
“This is a new playbook,” said Department of Housing Preservation and Development Commissioner Dina Levy in an interview. “This has extreme consequences financially and we are going to keep innovating to finally, at long lost, make them compliant or get out of the real estate business.”
She said the tactic aligns with Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s housing plan, which features a section called “Fix The City” with strategies for punishing “persistently negligent landlords.”
But the city’s legal argument in the new case against Singer remains untested.
In a written statement, Corporation Counsel Steven Banks said he was confident the False Claims Act can serve as a “powerful new tool to seek relief for tenants and hold landlords accountable for the public nuisances they have created in our communities.”