Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s long-awaited plan to close Rikers Island, released Friday, would empty the island’s jails by the end of 2032, moving the detainees held there to four new borough-based jails and three hospital units while turning the island itself over to climate and sustainability projects.

At the center of the plan is a sharp reduction in the city’s jail population over the next several years, to about two-thirds of the current 6,600 — a benchmark some advocates worry may be hard to meet and sustain in the decades ahead.

Even so, the proposal is the clearest sign yet that the first-year mayor intends to keep his campaign promise to shut down one of New York City’s most notorious institutions, known nationally for its chaos and dysfunction.

The effort to close Rikers Island has lurched along for nearly a decade, slowed by a global pandemic, construction delays and a previous mayoral administration that did little to move it forward. In recent years, city leaders acknowledged that they would not meet a legally mandated August 2027 closure deadline, but hadn’t offered a new timeline.

“Our administration is determined to meet our moral and legal obligation to close Rikers Island once and for all,” Mamdani wrote in a letter that opens the plan.

The new buildings, which are underway but years behind schedule, are designed to be safer and more humane, with smaller housing units, better sightlines, natural light and temperature control.

But advocates like Elizabeth Glazer, who helped write the original closure plan as former Mayor Bill de Blasio’s criminal justice director, warn that without broad reform across the Department of Correction, the city “risks merely exporting the violence of Rikers into new ZIP codes when the neighborhood-based facilities are completed.”

At least nine people have died in the Department of Correction’s custody this year, and not all of them on the island. In August, one man died in a new medical treatment outpost at Bellevue Hospital, the first facility to open as part of the replacement system for Rikers. Two others died at borough courthouses.

The administration still needs the City Council to formally adopt the plan. Councilmembers had signaled in September they were drafting a bill that would tie extensions to specific benchmarks and deadlines. Councilmember Sandy Nurse, who sponsored a 2025 law requiring the administration to release Friday’s report, called the plan “the right move.”

She described it as “a pulling together of work that has been agreed to [a] long time ago that just never was prioritized under Eric Adams, and some expansions into key areas that are going to help us achieve the target jail population.”

A women holds a placard during a protest to close down Rikers Island on Nov. 3, 2022.

The plan has also been well-received by advocates briefed on its contents ahead of its release. Zachary Katznelson, executive director of the Independent Rikers Commission, described the previous administration’s approach as “at best all over the map, but very often antagonistic to what we were trying to achieve.” But he said the new plan marked a “return to common sense” that would make New Yorkers safer.

Darren Mack, co-director of Freedom Agenda, which has long pushed to close Rikers, said advocates were excited by the strategy.

“We can finally remove this moral stain from our city, once and for all,” Mack added.

The Mamdani administration acknowledges risks in the strategic plan, calling Rikers a product of its remote location, failing infrastructure and “a culture of dysfunction that has persisted for generations.”

“We will not transfer the historic and endemic failures of Rikers to new locations across New York City,” the plan promises.

Decades of calls for a closure

Calls to close Rikers date back to at least the late 1970s, when then-Mayor Ed Koch first floated the idea of replacing the massive jail complex with smaller jails across the city’s boroughs. Closure gained real traction in the 2010s, inspired in part by the story of Kalief Browder, a Bronx teenager sent to Rikers in 2010 after being accused of stealing a backpack. He spent three years on Rikers, much of that time in solitary confinement. Eventually, his case was dismissed. Browder died by suicide two years later.

By 2017, a commission led by former Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman came to the conclusion that “Rikers must be closed.” De Blasio, who had previously resisted calls to build an entirely new system separate from the island, finally endorsed the project, calling Browder’s death “a wake-up call to this city.” Two years later, the City Council formally voted to move to the new borough-based jails even over fierce opposition from neighborhood groups.

At Rikers, out-of-sight, out of mind is the norm for both people in our custody and our staff.
Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards

As all of this played out, human rights abuses at Rikers mounted, and the city entered into a consent decree with a federal court over the use of force on the island. The judge in that case appointed a monitor to track the department's ongoing reform efforts.

“Close Rikers” advocates have long argued that the island itself was central to the dysfunction. The complex, for instance, sits on a gas-emitting former landfill. Buildings can’t be adequately cooled or ventilated. And thousands of cell doors are broken. What’s more, the island can only be reached by a single road, and a trip using public transit can take at least an hour and a half, which presents issues for families, lawyers and those who work there.

“At Rikers, out-of-sight, out of mind is the norm for both people in our custody and our staff,” Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards said in a video released with the plan.

Initially, the closure seemed within reach. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the jail population fell below 4,000 for the first time since the 1940s, the result of unprecedented cooperation between defense attorneys, prosecutors and court administrators to slow the spread of the coronavirus. The progress, however, was short-lived. Under the Adams administration, the jail population rebounded, borough-based jail construction lagged and costs nearly doubled.

Lezandre Khadu, the mother of Stephan Khadu, one of dozens of prisoners to die while under the custody of the New York City Department of Corrections, at a protest calling for the closer of Rikers in November 2023.

Meanwhile, conditions on Rikers have only festered. In January, the federal judge overseeing reforms handed broad control of the jails to a remediation manager, Nicholas Deml.

Reducing the jail population

Under Mamdani’s new plan, the borough-based jail system would come online gradually over the next six years. His administration has taken a few steps already, such as hiring the city’s first "Close Rikers Czar" and opening the Bellevue treatment unit. Two additional hospital units, one in the Bronx and one in Brooklyn, are expected to open by 2028. The first new jail facility would open in Brooklyn in 2029. The others would follow in 2031 and 2032.

Rikers facilities would be emptied and decommissioned as new beds become available. Altogether, the new facilities would have room for 4,500 people.

In order to make the transition work, the city will have to move quickly and forcefully to reduce the jail population. Under the plan, the city is aiming to get the jail population down to no more than 5,500 by the time the Brooklyn facility opens in 2029 — and then to 4,100 by the end of 2032.

In order to hit those figures, the administration is committing $290 million to expand diversion programs, supervised release, re-entry support and faster case processing.

One of the biggest challenges, according to the plan, is the slow pace of the city’s courts. The jail’s population didn’t grow as a result of more arrests, the plan argues, but rather because people are waiting longer for their cases to resolve.

In New York City, the median time between a felony arrest and a case’s final disposition is 431 days, roughly four months longer than in the rest of the state. At least 1,400 Rikers detainees have been awaiting trial for more than a year.

“We do not want any New Yorker to spend a day longer in detention than necessary,” Mamdani said in the release video.

Chief Administrative Judge Joseph Zayas said in a statement included in the plan that the courts “must not accept a status quo that tolerates excessive delay.”

Achieving this sort of population reduction will take cooperation on the scale of what happened during the COVID-19 pandemic, said Glazer, who is also the founder of the Vital City think tank and policy journal.

“In the same way that the police department has CompStat [a public data reporting system] about crime, the city needs to have a kind of jail stat about who’s in jail and why, how many people are coming in, and how long are they staying,” Glazer said. “That’s what drives the jail population, and that has to be looked at every single day.”

Mayor Zohran Mamdani and city Department of Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards at a 9/11 ceremony in September of this year.

The plan itself states the population estimate is “not meant to be a forecast.” While it notes that the new buildings could be adapted for other uses if the jail population were to continue shrinking, it doesn’t say anything about what the city will do if the figure remains above its target.

'Only half the challenge'

In his own letter attached to the plan, Richards, the first formerly incarcerated person to lead the Department of Correction, notes the new facilities “represent only half the challenge.”

“We must also build a safer, more supportive culture within our jails today, so that it is firmly established when we make the transition,” he wrote.

To that end, the plan pledges to replace the island’s 2,450 defective doors, improve sanitary conditions and “reimagine” staff training.

Much of that has been mandated by Deml, the remediation manager, who earlier this year noted that the Department of Correction struggled to perform basic correctional functions. The plan also accounts for a $50 million investment in programming for people in custody that Deml had recommended.

Christopher Rodriguez’s death at Bellevue in August illustrates the shortcomings of DOC training and protocol, regardless of facility. According to a Board of Correction report obtained by Gothamist, officers at the new unit had skipped required overnight tours in the time before the 36-year-old was found unresponsive. Six officers were suspended.

The entrance of the Rikers Island correction facility in Queens on Oct. 5, 2026.

Unions will be central to any reform, and the plan names the Correction Officers' Benevolent Association as a partner, noting the department has successfully worked with unions in the past to improve working conditions.

The union declined to comment Thursday on a summary of the plan. After publication of this article, COBA president Benny Boscio sent a statement praising the city’s willingness to partner with the union but said the prisoner population wind-down was unrealistic. The union instead called for investment in state-of-the-art facilities on Rikers Island, despite its legally mandated closure.

The administration “cannot build a safer NYC by simply reducing jail capacity,” Boscio wrote.

Nurse, the councilmember, blamed the union for years of stalled reform, but noted the remediation manager has the power to circumvent it.

“We have the right conditions right now,” Nurse said, adding that the mayor and the City Council are aligned.

“If we fail to do this, if we fail to successfully transition to these borough-based jails, it will be a huge embarrassment to the city,” Nurse said.

This story has been updated with more information.