Election Day in Westchester County got off to a rocky start on Tuesday with a county-wide failure of ballot-scanning machines. But officials from both parties encouraged voters to show up to the polls as normal and said all votes will be counted properly.

Westchester, just north of New York City, is one of several counties voting in the marquee congressional race between Republican Rep. Mike Lawler and Democratic challenger Cait Conley that could help determine control of Congress.

Lawler said at a press conference Tuesday afternoon that he expected all of the votes to be counted by the end of the night.

“Everybody who is on line should stay on line, should vote,” he told reporters. “Every vote is going to be counted and it’s going to be counted tonight.”

Conley similarly encouraged voters to stay at the polls and said the issue was being handled and resolved in a bipartisan way.

“The polls are open and operational, and every vote cast will be counted. Please stay in line and have your voice heard as they work to resolve the issue,” she said on social media.

The New York State Board of Elections said on social media that the mishap happened because it failed to properly deploy "updated election programming" for ballot scanners, and that it was working to restore one machine at each of the county’s polling places in order to scan and count ballots.

Westchester County Executive Ken Jenkins, a Democrat, said he is confident the final tally will be accurate.

“Voters should remain in line and exercise their right to vote,” Jenkins said in a statement. “Every eligible voter will have the opportunity to cast their ballot, and every vote must be counted.”

Not every voter sounded so sure.

“Not great,” Karina De La Rosa, a voter in Sleepy Hollow, said after leaving her polling place. “We're already hearing that the Republicans are, you know, they want to mess with what's going on right now because there's going to be a blue tsunami, so they say.”

De La Rosa told Gothamist she didn’t know there was a problem with the machine until she was done casting her ballot and a poll worker told her to put the ballot in a red bag.

“He's like, ‘Well, you have to put it in the sack,’” she said after voting. "I made a face.”

She said the workers at the site were familiar faces and all seemed prepared, but poll workers across the county are managing chaos.

“An old-timey manual process”

The Westchester Board of Elections initially said in a statement that a paper thickness problem prevented the devices from accepting ballots, but later updated the statement and removed mention of the issue. The county board is responsible for the ballots and the machines, which are supposed to be tested before Election Day.

By Tuesday afternoon, the single scanner workers programmed to accept ballots at each polling place began coming online, Jenkins said.

New York Democratic Congressional candidate Cait Conley speaks during a campaign stop on the eve of Election Day in New York.

Votes cast earlier in the day that could not be scanned were placed in emergency orange ballot bags. Lawler said those ballots would be transported from poll sites after 9 p.m. by police escort to a central location at the Board of Elections.

At the Board of Elections, workers will have access to approximately 10 vote scanning machines to count the ballots from the orange bags, Lawler said.

Earlier in the day, Sleepy Hollow Mayor Marjorie Hsu reminded voters that the process may feel antiquated because of the technical issues, but sought to reassure Westchester residents that they should vote as normal and that every ballot would be counted.

“Everything's being processed by an old-timey manual process, basically,” she told Gothamist.

She said voters should take care to fill in the ovals their paper ballots completely – indicating their candidate of choice – and then put the ballots into orange bags overseen by poll workers.

Gov. Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James joined the chorus of officials who tried to reassure Westchester voters. Both are also on the ballot this year as they seek re-election against their Republican challengers, County Executive Bruce Blakeman and Saritha Komatireddy, respectively. James said in a statement on social media that her office is also monitoring the issue.

Jenkins said the county would be conducting an investigation into what went wrong.

“Once these issues are resolved, I will convene a bipartisan team to conduct a thorough review of the decisions and failures that led to this debacle, determine where accountability lies and ensure that this never happens again,” Jenkins said in the statement.

“Westchester County voters deserve a fair, secure and seamless election process. Today, we have fallen short of that standard. The voters deserve better, and I intend to make sure they get it,” he added.

This is a developing story and has been updated.