It used to be that candidates would call themselves “pro-choice” or “pro-life” on abortion.
But now as the issue is debated in the run-up to the midterm elections, some New Jersey congressional hopefuls who want to appeal to more than the stalwarts on either side of the abortion issue are having a hard time explaining their positions.
Tom Kean Jr., who is trying to unseat two-term Democratic Rep. Tom Malinowski in the 7th District, is a prime example of the challenges potential voters face as they try to learn exactly where candidates stand on abortion rights.
Kean, a former state Senate Republican leader, was asked several times about his stance on abortion rights during a recent candidates’ forum. At least some in the audience found his answers unclear. Kean’s first response to a question on abortion drew the only admonition to the audience from the moderator when a number of people shouted out, including one asking, “I have to follow up on this: Do you support a woman’s right to choose or not?”
The moderator noted that Kean has a website in which he states he “is a fierce defender of the sanctity of life, fighting every step of the way to protect the unborn from egregious abortion laws proposed in New Jersey.” Kean said in answer to the question at the forum: “I support a woman’s right to choose … Like most New Jerseyans, I support reasonable restrictions. Those include the life and physical health and mental health of the mother and the baby, rape and incest, for example, with a reasonable length of time to make a decision.”
He went on to say that Malinowski supports “abortion on demand,” including in the last trimester.
Kean: ‘Egregious piece of law’
In one of his last acts as a state senator, Kean voted against a bill, now state law, that codified the freedom of reproductive choice. New Jersey is one of four states and the District of Columbia that have codified the right to abortion throughout pregnancy. That law made official the rights that the state Supreme Court had previously recognized, including the right to access contraception, terminate a pregnancy and carry a pregnancy to term. It also gives the right to reproductive choice to all individuals while in New Jersey, including nonresidents.
Kean called that “an egregious piece of legislation.”
Kean declined requests from NJ Spotlight News to discuss abortion and other issues. Following the forum, campaign spokesman Harrison Neely clarified Kean’s position. Neely said Kean believes a woman should have a right to an abortion through the first 20 weeks of pregnancy and with “reasonable restrictions” after that for rape, incest, and the health of the mother.
Fewer than 1% of all abortions, or less than 6,000, occur at or after 21 weeks, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and the Kaiser Family Foundation reports that most of these occur because the mother's life is endangered or because of fetal abnormalities. Nine out of 10 abortions are carried out in the first 13 weeks of pregnancy, the foundation reported.
Kaiser also notes that “viability,” or the ability for a fetus to survive outside the womb, depends on heart and lung development and other factors. It is generally not reached before 24 weeks; a typical pregnancy spans 40 weeks. Kaiser said 21 weeks is a “largely arbitrary” cutoff that reflects federal data collection metrics more than clinical experience.
Kean is a believer in states' rights and supports allowing the states to set their own abortion laws, Neely said. And Kean “does not support a national abortion ban,” Neely said.
Malinowski’s criticism
Malinowski’s campaign claimed Kean’s position shows he would support the national abortion ban proposed by Sen. Lindsay Graham of South Carolina and Rep. Chris Smith of New Jersey’s 4th District.
Neely called that “an outright lie.”
The proposed bill would ban abortions after 15 weeks. If enacted, it would supersede state laws in New Jersey and elsewhere. Republicans have said passing the ban is a priority if they take one or both houses of Congress after the November elections.
“For Tom Malinowski to continue to spin this lie … is just dishonest,” Neely said. “He is lying. Tom Kean’s position is as mainstream as it gets.”
Neely pointed to a June 2021 AP-NORC poll where 61% of Americans said abortion should be legal in all or most cases during the first trimester, but 65% said it should usually be illegal in the second trimester and 80% want it illegal in the third trimester. But in a poll soon after the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization decision that ended the federal right to abortion and sent the issue to the states, a majority said Congress should pass a law guaranteeing abortion rights.
In a statement, Malinowski, who is running ads critical of Kean’s views on abortion, said: “I will defend New Jersey’s laws that guarantee a woman’s right to choose, period.”
Since the U.S. Supreme Court rejected a constitutional right to abortion, “What we are watching to see is what kind of an impact the Dobbs decision has for women as voters and whether this will be an issue that energizes women and reinforces once again that elections have consequences,” said Debbie Walsh, director of the Center for Women and Politics at Rutgers University.
There is evidence that abortion could bring out more voters, but how much of an influence it may have is still unclear, Walsh said.
“Look at what happened in Kansas this summer. Clearly a very red state, and we saw a large turnout.”
Sherrill vs. DeGroot
In another contested congressional race, Democratic Rep. Mikie Sherrill is criticizing Paul DeGroot, her Republican opponent in the 11th District over what she says are his “extreme” positions on abortion in two ads. DeGroot has countered with the same charge against Sherrill, who supports abortion rights without exceptions.
“Since the Supreme Court overturned Roe, states across the country moved swiftly to ban abortion with no exceptions,” Sherrill said in a statement announcing one of the ads last month asserting DeGroot supports state abortion bans. “My opponent is fine with these laws because he thinks these decisions belong with government, not women … In Congress, I’ll continue to fight to keep politicians out of your personal health decisions and codify Roe. Paul DeGroot won’t.”
After the first ad began running, DeGroot — who had largely avoided talking to mainstream New Jersey media — held a news conference in which he said he supports the Dobbs decision making abortion a states' rights issue but does not think states should be able to ban abortion in cases of rape, incest, or to support the health of the mother. He also said he would not support a national abortion ban. And his personal opinion, DeGroot said, would be to allow abortions through 20 weeks.
In a Facebook video, DeGroot said Sherrill was “lying about my position on abortion because she wants to hide how extreme she is on this issue.” He then described his opinion as one very similar to Kean's, saying, “I support a woman’s right to choose through 20 weeks of pregnancy.”
Bob Hugin, chairman of the New Jersey Republican State Committee, said that candidates should talk about abortion when voters ask about it, but that it is not the major issue in the race.
“It’s inflation, inflation, inflation anywhere you go,” Hugin told reporters during a call on Friday. When candidates are out campaigning, meeting with voters, he said, “The first question they give is, how are you going to help us? What are we going to do? I can’t afford to drive to work. I have a small trucking company, I’ve got three trucks. I can’t buy the fuel.”
This article originally appeared on NJSpotlightnews.org and was provided to Gothamist.com. Find election guides and more election coverage at NJSpotlightnews.org.